Episode 1
Who's Your Daddy?! · Oct 27, 2023
80 acts across 20 episodes, 2023–2024. 21 of them fooled Penn and Teller — one season of all 568 acts the show has billed.
Who's Your Daddy?! · Oct 27, 2023
2 Dead in Tonight's Episode · Nov 3, 2023
Magic is Sexy · Nov 10, 2023
We've Got a Racoon Problem · Nov 17, 2023
The Bill-In-Penn's-Head Trick · Dec 1, 2023
Badass Brooke · Dec 8, 2023
The Princess and the Wizard · Dec 22, 2023
The Smallest Biggest Magic Trick Ever · Jan 12, 2024
Penn & Teller vs. A Magic Hamster · Jan 19, 2024
A Magical Punch in the Face · Jan 26, 2024
The Youngest Act in Fool Us History · Feb 2, 2024
It's Snot Magic! · Feb 16, 2024
Game of Drones · Feb 23, 2024
Brought To You by the Letter P · Mar 1, 2024
Dan Quayle Gets Shot by a T-Shirt Cannon · Mar 15, 2024
Matt Donnelly (The Mind Noodler)
FindMagic profile →Magicians Like to Spoon · Mar 22, 2024
It Takes Balls to be a Magician · Mar 29, 2024
Shut Up - You Fooled Us! · Apr 5, 2024
Magic is for the Birds · Apr 19, 2024
Now Teller Won't Shut Up · Apr 26, 2024
Fool Us has run for 11 seasons and 173 episodes, and nobody involved with the show keeps a public list of who performed on it. So we built one, from the episode-by-episode records below, and checked it act by act.
Acts are listed the way the show billed them, so a duo stays a duo. A magician who came back gets a separate entry for every visit, because the result can go either way on different nights — plenty of people lost one week and fooled Penn and Teller the next. When we could confirm a magician has a FindMagic profile, their name links straight to it, so you can see where they are performing now.
A red YouTube mark means we watched that link and it really is that performance. A grey one means we could not find the clip and the link runs a YouTube search instead — we would rather admit that than pass a guess off as the real thing. Right now 122 of 686 performances have a confirmed video, and we are still working through the rest.
A few segments where Penn or Teller competed instead of judging are kept in the list but left out of the Fooled them filter — somebody else was doing the judging, so they are not comparable. Last updated 2026-08-28, covering everything broadcast through 2025-12-05.
Checked against: Wikipedia — Penn & Teller: Fool Us · Reddit r/FoolUs — Complete Lists of Foolers, Performers, Performances · The CW Network YouTube · Magician Masterclass — Fool Us coverage
Spotted something wrong, or performed on the show and want your profile linked? Tell us and we will fix it.